“Democracy is a wonderful thing, Mr Burnham,’ he said wistfully. ‘It is a marvellous tamasha that keeps the common people busy so that men like ourselves can take care of all matters of importance. I hope one day India will also be able to enjoy these advantages – and China too, of course.” – Excerpt from River of Smoke by Amitav Ghosh.
River of Smoke is the second book of the Ibis trilogy. Like the first book, Sea of Poppies, it is set in early 19th century, against the backdrop of the opium trade between India and China, and explores the lives of various characters involved in the trade.
As against the Sea of Poppies, which was set mostly in India, a large portion of River of Smoke happens in Canton, the port thru which opium was imported to China. Balram Modi, a wealthy Parsi businessman from Bombay is carrying one of the largest consignments of opium ever on the Ship Anahita to Canton. Another ship, Redruth, carrying horticulturist Frederick Penrose and his assistant Paulette, who are in search of rare Chinese plants and flowers, is also heading towards Canton. Things take an unexpected turn when the Chinese emperor bans opium trade, resulting in some interesting social, political, and economic consequences.
There is no doubt that River of Smoke is a difficult book to read. It contains dialogues in multiple dialects – English, Hindi, Gujrati, Bhojpuri, Cantonse, pidgin etc., with little effort from the author to translate everything to English. Many a times, one has to judge the meaning of these dialogues by the context. There are words like pus pus, muchi, allo olo, gradmanzees, etc. One has to interpret the meaning of these words. Although making reading difficult and demanding, it give a unique flavor of authenticity to the narrative. And in spite of being laborious to read, it is by no means boring or dull.
The characters, some continued from ‘Sea of Poppies’ and some new, are engaging and there are interesting ways in which their stories crisscross each other. The author has presented early 19th century Canton beautifully. The depth of research which has gone in writing this book is commendable.
The book (and the trilogy) covers one of the most interesting and historically significant part of British-Indo-chinese history (the events leading to the Opium War). It is most certainly a captivating read of those who are interested in this slice of history.
I have read the first two books of this trilogy and I have no qualms declaring it one of the most epic and grand literary exercise undertaken by any Indian author. Eagerly waiting for the third installment.
PS: I received a complimentary copy of this book, in order to review it, from MySmartPrice Books. Know more about them here
4 thoughts on “Book Review: River of Smoke by Amitav Ghosh”
So how close a trilogy is this? Would you be able to follow this book if you haven’t read the first two?
Most of the story in River of Smoke (part 2) can be enjoyed standalone, even if you haven’t read Sea of Poppies (part 1). Part 1 and Part 2 have two distinct story tracks, which I believe will converge in part 3 (yet to be released)
A comment from me… I read the first one, and was waiting and waiting for the follow-up… And of course I read “a million books” in between. So when I openend Rive of Smoke I was thinking, hmm I don’t remember much from Sea of Poppies that’s for sure. But that didn’t matter at all. I enjoyed these two books immensly, they are terrific reads and you keep thinking as you read; let this book be endless…..!